Avoid IP trouble when entering the market

By Marcel Kortekaas, M.Sc. 1 December 2022

Patents are valuable when you’re protecting your own intellectual property. They’re a real pain when you’re on the other side. For example, when you want to launch a product that falls under someone else’s valid patent.

Say your freedom-to-operate (FTO) search turns up a problem: a patent that looks novel, inventive and still valid. You can’t ignore it or count on it being invalid. So how do you enter the market safely? You have four options.

 

1. Licence

Ask the patent holder for a licence to make or use the invention. The patent register sometimes even says licences are available. You then agree the fee, the term and the markets it covers.

There are several types of licence:

  • Exclusive licence: only the licensee can make or use the invention. Even the patent holder has to stop.
  • Sole licence: one licensee, plus the patent holder, can use the invention commercially.
  • Non-exclusive licence: the patent holder decides how many others to license.
  • Cross-licence: two parties license each other. Both get access to new technology without stepping on each other’s toes.
  • Licence pool: several companies grant licences jointly.

Does the patent holder have to grant a licence?

No, a patent holder doesn’t have to grant a licence. It’s different if the patent holder dominates the market. If a patent is essential to a standard, such as 4G or Wi-Fi, the holder usually can’t refuse a licence on fair, reasonable terms. Refusing could breach EU competition law.

2. Buy your competitor’s patent, or the whole company

You might be able to buy the patent, for example at a patent auction. The holder may be willing, or even want to sell the whole company. Patents are one reason large companies buy smaller ones. Bayer, for example, bought seed and crop protection company Monsanto in 2018. (Competition law plays a role here too.)

3. Design around the patent

Engineer-around, work-around and design-around all mean the same thing: designing your product so it falls outside the patent. Have the patent examined carefully, so you know exactly how much room you have.

Swapping the patent’s screw for a nail usually isn’t enough. A court may well treat this as an equivalent, so you could still be accused of infringing.

Fortunately, there’s usually a way round. And it sometimes leads to new inventions you didn’t expect.

 

4. Patience

Patent rights always expire. Sometimes it’s just a matter of waiting before you can enter the market freely.

In short: if you risk infringing someone else’s IP rights, there are plenty of ways to respect them and still enter the market safely.

The risks of doing business without a patent strategy

 

About the author

I’ll never forget an inventor excitedly showing me splintered wood after we developed a polyketone adhesive that passed extreme boiling water tests. That success marked the start of a new business....

More about Marcel >