Dealing with infringement: your action plan

By Walter Hart, M.Sc. 1 December 2022

Take-action-against-infringement?-This-is-how-you-can-tackle-it-smartly-(9/9)

You’ve identified an infringement and gathered evidence properly. Your ‘friendly or forceful letter’ asking them to stop hasn’t worked. Then it’s time to serve a summons, to start either preliminary relief proceedings or substantive proceedings. Which should you choose?

Preliminary relief proceedings  Substantive proceedings
  • Choose this if you’re confident about both validity and infringement, and want to stop the infringer fast.
  • Choose this for complex cases, where validity or infringement is open to debate.
  • The court usually gives a provisional decision within about two months: a temporary ban, or not. If in doubt, the court won’t impose a ban.
  • The court normally rules within about 13 months.
  • After that you are obliged to commence substantive proceedings within 30 days.
 
  • If the court does not issue a provisional ban on infringement and you disagree with this, you can take your case to the Court of Appeal.
  • If you disagree with the decision you can take your case to the Court of Appeal. After this it is possible to appeal in cassation at the Supreme Court in some cases.

Tips

Whichever route you choose, preparation is vital. Here are four tips.

1. The summons has to be rock solid

Take your time to draw up the summons properly. Why? 

In principle an infringement only exists if the product contains all features that have been claimed in the patent’s independent claims (often claim 1). So if the other party’s machine or product contains a part that is not mentioned in the independent claim, in principle there is no infringement and you will lose the case.

The other party stands to make off with the profits if your patent was wrongly granted, for example if:

This is why the invention needs to be presented in the summons in a clear and convincing manner, preferably in such a way that the invention gets the court’s support.

It is very important to ensure that the summons does not contain any weaknesses. ‘One rotten egg spoils the omelette.’ Weak arguments, incorrect statements and suchlike must be avoided at all cost.

2. Make sure you engage the right solicitor

You need a patent law specialist. IP law also covers trademarks and copyright, and a lawyer who’s strong there isn’t necessarily strong in patents.

Some lawyers are better at defending patents, others at attacking them. Ask your network or your patent attorney to recommend someone who could represent you in an infringement case.

 

3. Make sure your expectations are realistic

Discuss your chances with your solicitor and patent attorney. Are your chances of winning realistic? This is important as you will have to pay the other party's costs if you lose. You should ask some probing questions if you hear: 'this is a challenging case' because this might mean the solicitor is of the opinion that you could very well lose the case. 

4. Prepare a settlement strategy

Have a settlement strategy before you serve the summons. Few infringement cases reach court, and many of those settle before a ruling.

For the infringer, the business risk is often huge: if they lose, they have to stop. For the patent holder, the risk is often smaller. Losing usually just means the status quo continues, and the existing infringement carries on. So the risks are often unevenly spread.

As a patent holder, you can use that. Even if your chances of winning are fairly small, it can still be wise to start proceedings. Not to win a ruling, but to get a better deal along the way. Positions shift under pressure, and a good lawyer can achieve a lot.

Finally

In infringement cases, I believe it often pays to serve a summons. A summons is a sword you let glint in the sun, to make your opponent think twice. It doesn’t have to end in a ruling. The best settlements are often reached under pressure.

About the author

My father was a successful inventor and I have been raised with technical creativity throughout my childhood. However, I always knew that was not enough for me. I like language, law, business &...

More about Walter >