Patent: right to prohibit use, not to use

By Wendy van Zoelen, Ph.D. 1 December 2022

Patent: right to prohibit use, not to use (part 3)

I’ve already covered two common misconceptions about patents. Is a patent an easy way to make money, or an expensive waste of it? Neither is true, and a good patent attorney will always protect you from these pitfalls, as well as from this third, incorrect idea: that a patent gives you the right to use an invention.

It sounds back to front. Isn’t a patent a licence to use your product? No. A patent is the right to stop others doing something. Inventions and their patents often overlap with patents belonging to others. So a patent on your product doesn’t automatically let you sell it.

When patents overlap

Imagine bicycles exist, but bicycles with brakes don’t yet. Party X has a patent on a bicycle, and you develop a bicycle with brakes. If your bicycle is inventive compared with the earlier one, you can get a patent on a bicycle with brakes.

X now has a patent on a bicycle, and you have one on a bicycle with brakes. You can stop X making a bicycle with brakes. But X can stop you making a bicycle at all. So your patent doesn’t automatically let you make and sell your product.

That doesn’t mean your bicycle will never go on sale. It means you need a proper agreement with X. You need something from them, and they probably want something from you. Together, you’ll still have a big head start on other competitors. So talk about your rights, so you can both get on with business.

Freedom-to-operate study

To get this right, a patent attorney carries out a freedom-to-operate (FTO) study. They search for patents held by others that your product might infringe. It shows you whose patents overlap with yours.

You can then get the most from your product, despite, or even thanks to, those overlaps. That keeps you out of trouble over this third misconception, and means you can actually use your product.

Transforming patents into business strategy

 

About the author

I began as a polymer chemist, but my passion shifted toward supporting the journey of innovation rather than conducting research. Becoming a patent attorney allowed me to transition into safeguarding...

More about Wendy >